VivaBarnesLaw
Politics • Culture • News
This is the VivaBarnesLaw Community.
Interested? Want to learn more about the community?

https://www.facebook.com/InstitutefortheStudyofWar/posts/pfbid0kLNxrkDcJeNKHArdNsf4Q7ULmmiGUGhQa5Sxmg6ekEzj1s32fP7eUH7Di8GbjSkgl

Institute for the Study of War, on Pokrovsk. Reads like a professionally written piece, meaning that they are mostly truthful, BUT have heavy caveats to their conditions and implied meaning based on word choice. I'll break this down in detail below.

Here's their post verbatim:
NEW: Data on Russian forces’ rate of advance indicates that a Russian military victory in Ukraine is not inevitable, and a rapid Russian seizure of the rest of Donetsk Oblast is not imminent.
Recent Russian advances elsewhere on the frontline have largely been opportunistic and exploited seasonal weather conditions. Ukrainian forces have proven effective at constraining Russian advances and conducting successful counteroffensives, particularly when well-staffed and well-equipped.
Russian Offensive Campaign Assessment, November 26, 2025: https://isw.pub/UkrWar11262025
Other Key Takeaways:
Kremlin officials continue setting conditions to reject any peace deal that does not concede to all of Russia’s maximalist demands.
The Kremlin is reportedly concerned that the United States will correctly interpret Russia as unwilling to meaningfully engage in negotiations and accept any peace deal that compromises its ability to achieve its maximalist claims.
Recent Ukrainian counterattacks may further delay Russian forces’ seizure of Pokrovsk, though the situation in Pokrovsk remains serious and dynamic at this time.
Russia continues setting conditions to deploy active reservists to combat against Ukraine.
Russia’s long-range strike campaign is increasingly killing and injuring civilians.
Ukrainian forces recently advanced near Hulyaipole. Russian forces recently advanced near Lyman.

Here's the quick TLDR:
Russian breakthrough in 1x area is likely or imminent (Pokrovsk), a possible around Udache, Kupiansk and around the direction near Pokrovs'ke, but those aren't quite as imminent as Pokrovsk.

Note their typical use of language to try and couch the conversation:

Data on Russian forces’ rate of advance indicates that a Russian military victory in Ukraine is not inevitable, and a rapid Russian seizure of the rest of Donetsk Oblast is not imminent. -> "inevitable", "imminent", "rapid". The rate of advance is the highlight, not to the inevitability of defeat. Meaning their full argument states that a fall of Donetsk does not preclude a fall of the whole country. While this should be fairly obvious, this is used to distinguish them from the pundits. The pundits will take and sensationalize everything, with click-bait titles like COLLAPSE OF UKRAINE IMMINENT. or RUSSIAN RELIEF COLUMN DESTROYED BY UAVS. Almost everything is stupidly hyperbolic at all times. This use of nuance and reasoned language, draws you into the professional sensibilities and builds their credibility.

Recent Russian advances elsewhere on the frontline have largely been opportunistic and exploited seasonal weather conditions. Ukrainian forces have proven effective at constraining Russian advances and conducting successful counteroffensives, particularly when well-staffed and well-equipped.
-> Has two main factors here. Weather, and staffing/equipment.
The weather portion is true. Bad weather means UAVs don't fly too well, air support gets grounded, so artillery is back to being the undisputed king. Conversely, bad weather also means logistics support is slow, so no quick breakthrough. There isn't much revelatory about these.
On staffing and manning, it is almost a stupid, blatant, and obvious statement. But note the wording. Of course, a full-on Ukrainian force with the correct equipment, leadership, manning, training, etc, will be able to resist and counter a Russian attack. But we also know that is not the case too for the average Ukrainian unit. The use of the word "particularly", implies that this is the exception and not the rule. Already, we know that Ukrainian units are undermanned to the tune of operating at around 60-70% manning (See https://www.osw.waw.pl/en/publikacje/osw-commentary/2025-03-14/army-a-crossroads-mobilisation-and-organisational-crisis), while sometimes tasked with overly large areas (See https://empr.media/opinion/analytics/absolute-wartime-record-how-one-ukrainian-brigade-holds-5-of-the-entire-active-front/). So chances are.....most units struggle regardless of how you cut it. And this is absent from the analysis.

What follows are a bunch of quick statements, mostly reporting on Kremlin thoughts on a ceasefire, and locations for frontline advance. Here are the standouts in their statements.

Recent Ukrainian counterattacks may further delay Russian forces’ seizure of Pokrovsk, though the situation in Pokrovsk remains serious and dynamic at this time.
-> "may", "serious and dynamic". Translation: Pokrovsk is about to fall.

Taken together, ISW has done a very professionally written piece. It requires you to have a bit of contextual knowledge to grasp that they are actually talking about some things out loud, albeit deliberately phrased in neutral-scientific terminology, contrasting the sensationalist social media accounts. And in doing so, is a form of persuasion.

Interested? Want to learn more about the community?
What else you may like…
Videos
Podcasts
Posts
Articles
November 24, 2025
Lighthouse off Robbie Marina

The barracuda was easily 5 ft long.

00:04:19
November 23, 2025
A treasure we found at a Florida key antique store

The antique shop is at Robbie’s Marina. A civil war cannonball. Now to see if it’s a treasure, or a paperweight!

00:00:52
November 22, 2025
this is the manatee

manatees are humans living in animals skin. I swear we had a moment.

00:01:36
February 17, 2024
Appearance on Richard Syrette

I did a quick hit on Richard Syrette yesterday. Gotta keep Canadians apprised of the U.S. madness.

Appearance on Richard Syrette
The Barnes Brief, Podcast Format: Monday, July 17, 2023

Closing Argument: Birthright citizenship is deeply American, and wholly Constitutional.

The Barnes Brief, Podcast Format: Monday, July 17, 2023
Declaration of Independence

Audio podcast style.

Declaration of Independence
Thanksgiving Day Thoughts

This is now my 4th year living in America. American Thanksgiving is different than Thanksgiving in Canada. People take it much more seriously here. At least in my personal / digital sphere. And it's a thing of beauty.

It is a good reminder.

To be grateful even for the "problems". I left some dirty exercise clothing lying on the floor - smelly, wet from sweat. My wife said tongue-in-cheek "I'm grateful you exercise, and it's better than beer cans. Now pick it up!"

I find gratitude a tough feeling to truly, beyond the words, appreciate. My tendency is to focus on problems, real or perceived, and in the absence of problems, to fear the potential / inevitability of problems.

Also, the guilt that while I have so much to be grateful for, there are others who are experiencing difficulties that we can only barely imagine. How one can feel gratitude without guilt is something of an internal battle for me.

With that said, there is the old proverb (it's not really a proverb): If you have the ...

Dogs are God’s gift to man

These two guys were initially a little skiddish. But they’ve warmed up!

post photo preview
post photo preview
post photo preview
The Barnes Brief: Weekend of November 21, 2025

I.    INTRODUCTION

A. Art of the Day

We the People. It stands out above all in the scribed parchment inside the glass-encased shield inside the Rotunda of Congress with three words bigger than the rest: We The People. Penned on a single sheet of animal skin by Jacob Shallus, it stands out as the Great Charter of American liberty, the profound experiment in self-government, and still stands today as the oldest and shortest written constitution of any major government in the world today. Those words stand out above the rest, written in flowing letters outsized to the text, to remind the world upon what power our government sits: We the People.

B. Wisdom of the Day

“Monopoly is a great enemy” and a “wretched spirit” which poses a greater threat to the free market than as it prevents free enterprise from self-defense. Adam Smith.

C. Cultural Recommendation

Ratification: The People Debate the Constitution tells the tale of what the true founders – the generation that birthed freedom on this continent – thought as they argued the merits of this new document. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7841680-ratification

D. Appearances

II.                         THE EVIDENCE

 *Note: A reminder — links are NOT endorsements of the ideas contained therein. The Library is big, and it mostly consists of ideas I do not personally share.  

 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
The Barnes Brief: Wednesday, November 19, 2025

I. INTRODUCTION

A. Art of the Day

One place where AI proves fun is its image generation capacity, whether for memes, dystopian dreams, otherworldly experiences, or translating photos and ideas into the templated work of famous painters. I asked it to convert this meme into a Hopper painting, and it turns out quite fun, as it blurs and blends the images into the spirit of the people and place, as Hopper so masterfully made so often. A Hush Hush of its own accord.

B. Wisdom of the Day

“AI is unfalsifiable and thus unscientific.” Erik Larson.

C. Cultural Recommendation

The Myth of Artificial Intelligence: Why Computers Can’t Think the Way We Do. The author, an AI researcher himself, explains why much of AI’s narrative is pure fiction.

D. Appearances

II.     THE EVIDENCE

 *Note: A reminder — links are NOT endorsements of the ideas contained therein. The Library is big, and it mostly consists of ideas I do not personally share.  

 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
post photo preview
The Barnes Brief: Weekend of November 14, 2025

I.   INTRODUCTION

A. Art of the Day

Working away in the hidden office, devouring intel and discovering information, to share with the world. My office looks like this, but replaced with digital feeds over the physical ones of yesteryear, processing the running feeds into recognizable patterns that can both explicate and forecast alike. To all the hidden offices uncovering what his hidden for the world.

B. Wisdom of the Day

“You will never understand bureaucracies until you understand that, for bureaucrats, procedure is everything and outcomes are nothing.” Thomas Sowell.

C. Cultural Recommendation

The Dark Side of H1B Visa exposed by a recipient, Raj Kuppa. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25843858-the-dark-side-of-h1b-visa

D. Appearances

II.    THE EVIDENCE

 *Note: A reminder — links are NOT endorsements of the ideas contained therein. The Library is big, and it mostly consists of ideas I do not personally share.  

 

Only for Supporters
To read the rest of this article and access other paid content, you must be a supporter
Read full Article
See More
Available on mobile and TV devices
google store google store app store app store
google store google store app tv store app tv store amazon store amazon store roku store roku store
Powered by Locals